Economic Commentary
The positive Rugby World Cup result gave welcome relief from
the general economic gloom. However, the global financial crisis grinds steadily along
regardless of the short-term boost to spending in New Zealand.
The outlook for the
Australian and New Zealand economies is clouding, although still better
than most Western economies. Both
are dependent on international commodity markets and are vulnerable to a
further global recession. Australia
is still heavily dependent on the Chinese demand for its raw minerals.
The high Australian dollar has severely eroded manufacturing
exports. China’s growth
has slowed and could fall further in 2012.
In the meantime hard commodities prices have fallen, the spot
price for copper dropping 25% in September.
The latest ratings
downgrades of New Zealand by both Standard & Poors and Fitch are a
reaction to the high private borrowing, a persistent government deficit
and the lack of structural reform to reduce these.
There is also nervousness that the major Australian banks could
be downgraded, thus increasing their costs of borrowing as international
credit markets tighten. Heavy
exposures to the mining industry and to the (still overvalued)
Australian housing market are other sources of vulnerability for the
Australian banks (which are major players in New Zealand).
Debt woes are still
hampering the global recovery, with those in Europe proving to be the
least sustainable. The
announcements this week of 50% write-downs on Greek debt by the banks
and a much enlarged rescue fund are light on detail, but indicate that
the major European players would prefer a move towards further fiscal
integration to disintegration of the Euro.
While the markets have responded favourably to this news, we
reserve judgement until the debts have either been forgiven or arranged
to be repaid.
The Bank of England has
continued its quantitative easing programme in an effort to reduce
borrowing costs although this is likely to increase inflation.
With recent U.K. annual inflation already about 4.5%, any further
rise will be bad news for savers - especially since further easing is
expected in the New Year.
The
sell-off of stock markets has been combined with a strengthening of the
U.S. dollar as the Euro has weakened.
This has benefited exporters in both Australia and New Zealand.
We are still concerned by the American economy because of high
unemployment and political paralysis.
The latest quantitative easing by Ben Bernanke called
‘twisting’ (selling short-dated treasuries and buying long-dated
ones) has forced down the yield on long-dated bonds thus reducing the
income for savers and weakening the balance sheets of defined benefit
pension plans. Whilst
inflation is contained at present this process will damage the U.S.
public sector balance sheet when interest rates eventually rise to
counter rising inflation.
The
next three to six months will be volatile for stock markets with
potentially more falls as investors come to terms with the difficulties
faced by politicians and central bankers.
The austerity measures will cause further unrest and won’t be
as effective at solving the problems as policymakers hope.
Another credit crunch is the biggest risk.